I first stepped into Benningtons Antique Center through its unassuming front door and immediately felt like I had entered a curatorial dream. This multi-dealer antique center in the heart of Montgomery offers everything from vintage clothing and Pyrex to pottery, art, jewelry, and retro prints. Nestled in Orange County, New York, this doesn’t feel like a thrift store—it feels like a time capsule full of thoughtfully chosen treasures.
Market Details
- Address: 40 Railroad Ave, Montgomery, NY 12549
- Phone: (845) 457-7100
- Market Opening Hours:
| Wednesday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–5 PM |
Parking, Tickets & Transportation
I usually drive in and find easy street or lot parking near the center. Admission is always free, making a pop-in as casual as a walk through the village. Whether I’m stopping by on a whim or planning a browsing day, getting there is always seamless.
Vendor Information
Under new ownership, the center shines brighter than ever. Dozens of booths offer a curated blend of vintage clothing, Pyrex dishes, handmade pottery, art prints, jewelry, mid-century décor, and quirky collectibles. I’ve spent hours finding unique pieces that feel personally meaningful—whether it’s a retro sign or a handcrafted mug displaying surprising craftsmanship. Explore Tri-County Bazaar for multi-region shopping
Tips for First Timers
Weekday visits are optimal—you’ll have room to browse slowly and chat with dealers. Bring cash in small bills for easier bargaining, though card acceptance is becoming more common. And bring a tote—whether you’re hunting for small prints or more substantial furniture, there’s plenty to pack.
Why Benningtons Antique Center Is a Must-Visit
There’s a depth here that’s rare. I’ve found vintage postcards worth framing, decorative tools turned chic conversation pieces, and pottery that seems imbued with history. The space balances chaos and curation, and each corner tells a story—as if each visit invites you to write your own.
Visit Brooklyn Flea for NYC vintage finds
Instagram-Worthy Market Moments
I’ve captured the warm glow of soft lighting bouncing off vintage glassware, color-rich Pyrex stacked like rainbows, and quirky signage framed by rustic shelves. The combination of vintage charm and visual layers makes it a truly photogenic experience.
FAQs
What are the store hours?
Open Tuesday through Sunday, from 11 am to 5 pm, closed Mondays
Is there a fee to enter?
No—admission is free.
What items can I find there?
Expect a mix of vintage clothing, kitchenware, pottery, art, jewelry, textiles, and collectibles across eras.
How do I become a vendor?
Vendor details are available via their website or by calling the center directly.
Is parking available?
Yes—free parking is available nearby, and the center is easy to reach within the village.
Final Thoughts
Every visit to Benningtons Antique Center feels like uncovering a hidden chapter of design, craftsmanship, and local rhythm. Whether I leave with treasure in hand or simply inspiration in mind, the experience is always worth it. If you’re exploring Orange County, add it to your list—it might just surprise you in the best possible way. Come visit, soon—I promise you won’t be disappointed! Explore New York Flea Markets – An essential guide to flea markets across New York State, spotlighting standout spots in cities, countryside fairs, and market events.
